Reviewed by Marcus Maximo, Natural Farm Pet Expert · Updated April 2026
Bully Sticks vs Rawhide: Quick Answer
- Rawhide is a leather industry byproduct treated with bleach and chemical preservatives. It is largely indigestible and a known choking and blockage risk.
- Bully sticks are single-ingredient beef muscle, fully digestible, high in protein, and 100% odour-free when properly processed.
- Most Australian vets recommend against rawhide and favour natural, single-ingredient alternatives like bully sticks for everyday chewing.
Recommended for dogs 6 months and older. Always supervise your dog with any chew.
If you're comparing bully sticks vs rawhide for your dog, walk down the aisle of almost any pet store in Australia and you'll see shelves stacked with cheap, bleached-white chews. Most of them are rawhide. And most Australian vets will tell you the same thing: put them back.
This guide breaks down exactly what rawhide is, why it's a problem, and why odour-free bully sticks have become the go-to safe alternative for Australian dog owners who want their dog occupied without the vet bill that can follow.
This guide focuses on the bully sticks vs rawhide comparison. For the full AU bully sticks buying guide, see Bully Sticks Australia: The Ultimate Odour-Free Guide.
Part of our Australian bully sticks series: Bully Sticks Australia Guide · What Are Bully Sticks Made Of? · Best Long-Lasting Dog Chews · Best for Strong Chewers · Shop Bully Sticks
In This Guide:
What Is Rawhide and Why Is It Dangerous?
Despite the name, rawhide has nothing to do with raw meat or natural ingredients. It is a byproduct of the leather tanning industry. The outer skin of cattle is split during leather production, and the inner layer is what gets turned into those white chews you see on pet store shelves.
To get from a raw animal hide to a shelf-ready product, it goes through a chemical process involving bleach, hydrogen peroxide, and artificial preservatives. Some manufacturers add artificial flavouring on top of that to make it appealing to dogs. The end product is technically not food; it is a chemically treated hide shaped like a chew.
Vet Warning: According to Vet Voice Australia, rawhide is one of the more common causes of gastrointestinal obstruction in dogs. Swallowed chunks can rehydrate and swell inside the digestive tract, causing severe pain and blockages that may require emergency surgery. In Australia, that procedure typically costs between $3,000 and $8,000 AUD.
Why Bully Sticks Are the Safer Alternative
Bully sticks are made from a single ingredient: grass-fed beef pizzle (dried beef muscle). That is it. No chemical treatment, no bleaching, no artificial preservatives. The slow-roast drying process uses heat over 72+ hours, which removes moisture that would otherwise cause odour and eliminates the bacterial load common to poorly processed chews.
The critical difference from rawhide is digestibility. Bully sticks tend to break down in a dog's digestive tract the same way any other protein-based food does. If a piece is swallowed, the body generally processes it. There is no swelling, no obstruction risk, and no emergency vet visit. This is precisely the danger that Australian veterinary experts at Vet Voice flag with rawhide: chunks can get lodged in the oesophagus or digestive tract, rehydrate, and swell. RSPCA Australia recognises appropriate chewing as a normal behaviour that should be channelled toward safe, digestible chews.
On Odour: Many Aussie dog owners have avoided bully sticks because of the smell that comes with cheaper, poorly processed versions. The odour is a processing problem, not an ingredient problem. Natural Farm bully sticks are slow-roasted for 72+ hours and water-cleaned to be 100% odour-free. No smell on your hands, furniture, or carpet. For the full explanation, see Why Do Bully Sticks Smell?
Head-to-Head Comparison: Rawhide vs Bully Sticks
Here is how the two chews compare across every variable that actually matters to Australian dog owners.
| Feature | Traditional Rawhide | Natural Farm Bully Sticks |
|---|---|---|
| Digestibility | Largely indigestible, high blockage risk | Fully digestible |
| Ingredients | Leather byproduct, bleach, preservatives | Single ingredient: grass-fed beef muscle |
| Odour | Chemical smell, unpleasant residue | 100% odour-free |
| Nutritional Value | Minimal nutritional benefit | High protein, natural amino acids |
| Choking Risk | High: chunks may swell and obstruct | Low: breaks down safely if swallowed |
| Chemical Treatment | Bleach, hydrogen peroxide, preservatives | None: water-cleaned, heat-dried only |
| Vet Recommendation | Generally not recommended | Widely recommended as a safer alternative |
Natural Farm Odour-Free Bully Sticks for Australian Dogs
Most pet treat brands in Australia do not manufacture what they sell. They often import from multiple overseas suppliers and repackage locally, with limited direct control over raw materials, processing conditions, or consistency batch to batch. When something goes wrong, they may have little visibility into where it started.
Natural Farm manufactures and packages at origin, controlling every step from grass-fed cattle to finished product. Single ingredient throughout. Produced in USDA-approved, human-grade facilities under international quality standards. Third-party lab tested. No fillers, no binders, no artificial preservatives. Aligned with PFIAA standards for the Australian market. For a broader look at all chew options, see our Ultimate Guide to Long-Lasting Dog Chews in Australia.
Why supply chain transparency matters: The 2018 FDA and CDC investigation into Salmonella-contaminated rawhide traced the source back to imported products where the supply chain was untraceable. "Made in Australia" on the label tells you where it was packed. It tells you little about where the hide came from or how it was processed.
Not sure which size or type is right for your dog?
Our bundles let you try multiple chew formats at a better price. Great for first-time buyers making the switch from rawhide.
Explore Bundles and SaveSave on every order
Subscribe and get 15% off every delivery. Cancel any time.
Subscribe & Save 15% OffFrequently Asked Questions
Is rawhide banned in Australia?
Rawhide is not currently banned in Australia, but it is not regulated as a food product either. It falls into a grey area as a pet accessory rather than a treat, which means there are no mandatory safety or digestibility standards applied to it. Many Australian vets advise against it regardless of regulatory status, citing the documented risks of intestinal obstruction and chemical contamination from imported products.
Are bully sticks safer than rawhide for my dog?
Yes. Bully sticks are single-ingredient grass-fed beef pizzle that digests safely in the stomach. Rawhide is a leather industry byproduct, chemically treated, and largely indigestible. When a dog swallows a piece of rawhide, it can swell and cause an intestinal blockage. When a dog swallows a piece of a bully stick, it breaks down like any other protein. This is the main reason Australian vets generally recommend natural muscle chews over rawhide.
Are bully sticks safe if my dog swallows a piece?
Yes. Unlike rawhide, bully sticks are made from beef muscle, which an Aussie dog's digestive system tends to handle the same way it handles any other protein. If a piece is swallowed, it generally breaks down. The standard safety rule still applies: remove the chew when it gets small enough to be swallowed whole in one go, to avoid the risk of gulping a large final piece.
What should I do if my dog swallowed a piece of rawhide?
If your dog swallowed a small piece, monitor closely for the next 24 to 48 hours. Signs of a blockage can include vomiting, lethargy, loss of appetite, abdominal pain, or straining to defecate. If any of these appear, contact your Australian vet immediately. Rawhide chunks can rehydrate inside the digestive tract and swell to several times their dry size, which is why even a piece that seemed small can cause an obstruction. Do not wait to see if it passes on its own if your dog shows any distress.
What are the best rawhide alternatives for strong chewers in Australia?
For Aussie dogs that demolish a standard bully stick quickly, the two best natural alternatives are Collagen Sticks (denser, longer-lasting, supports joint health) and Power Bully Sticks (dual-layer beef construction designed for dogs like Staffies, Kelpies, and Bull Arabs). Both are single-ingredient, fully digestible, and free from the risks associated with rawhide. See our guide to the best bully sticks for aggressive chewers and the full long-lasting chews guide.
Can puppies have bully sticks instead of rawhide?
Bully sticks are appropriate for Aussie puppies from 6 months of age, once their adult teeth have started coming through and their digestive systems are more developed. Rawhide is particularly poorly suited to puppies because their immune systems are less equipped to handle potential chemical contamination and their smaller throats make choking more likely. A bully stick sized to your puppy's weight is a safer way to satisfy their natural urge to chew. For the full guide, see Are Bully Sticks Safe for Puppies?
Where can I buy safe rawhide alternatives in Australia?
Natural Farm Odour-Free Bully Sticks are available directly from naturalfarmpet.com.au, shipped Australia-wide from our Brisbane office. Free shipping on orders over $75 AUD. Delivery typically takes 2-4 business days for NSW, VIC, and ACT, 1-3 days for QLD, and up to 7 days for WA and NT. Available in Standard, Extra Thick, Large 12", and Power formats.
How much do rawhide-free bully sticks cost in Australia?
Natural Farm bully sticks start at $19.95 AUD for Standard 6", $21.95 AUD for Extra Thick, $37.99 AUD for Large 12", and $26.95 AUD for Power Bully Sticks. Prices include GST. Free shipping applies on orders over $75 AUD. Subscribe & Save members get 15% off every delivery. While supermarket rawhide is cheaper per unit, the potential vet costs from obstructions typically outweigh the savings.
Related Articles
About Natural Farm
Single-ingredient dog chews and treats, 100% grass-fed, produced in USDA-approved human-grade facilities under international quality standards, third-party lab tested, and shipped to Australian dog owners with free delivery on orders over $75 AUD. Aligned with PFIAA standards for the Australian market.